One evening a family of killer whales were out for a
late-night swim. There was a mom, dad, two sisters and a brother. Of course,
the brother loved to pester his sisters, as most brothers do. Tonight was just
like any other night. The water was calm, the sky was clear, and there were no
boats around. It was peaceful.
Brother wanted to swim closer to the shore so he could get a
better look at the sky. He had always had a fascination with the stars. Since
it was so quiet out, Mom and Dad agreed. He was so excited to see what constellations
would be visible this time. Last time he looked, he saw the Revolving Man and Revolving Woman, as well as the Black God and Great Bear constellations.
He swam as fast as he could towards the shore, like most
kids do when they’re excited about something. Mom and Dad just chuckled as they
watched their son light up as he swam ahead. They never minded letting him look
at the stars. The thing that always held them back were the people that lived
not far from the shore line. They had always heard stories about the people catching
whales and not letting them return to the water. Since it was a calm and
peaceful night, they decided to let their son follow his passion.
As Brother was looking up at the stars, trying to pinpoint
exactly what he was looking for, he heard a rustle in the bushes right off the
water. At first, he thought nothing of it. There was a slight breeze so he
brushed it off. He continued to admire the sparkle of the stars. With each
twinkle, he felt they were trying to talk to him. That was their way of
communicating. Their twinkle was a little different tonight. It almost seemed
to be panicky, as if they were trying to warn him.
Mom, Dad and the sisters were still a couple hundred feet
away. Close enough to see Brother, but far enough not to be near the surface.
Sisters were always scared to get near the shore because of the horror stories
their friends would tell on the way home from their swims. Soon, their fears
were going to be proven correct.
Brother was fascinated with everything he was seeing. It was
such a clear night that he could see The First Slender One, Butterfly, Place of Decisions, and many more. As he was trying to hunt down the Coyote constellation, he was
suddenly hit by something. At first, he jerked some because it startled him. As
he did, he felt whatever hit him wrap around his body. He tried to fight it,
but it just got tighter and he couldn’t break free. He called out for Mom and Dad, but they were just far enough away they couldn't reach him in time.
As they were swimming frantically towards him, he disappeared out of the
water.
There was nothing they could do but to let him go. If they
got any closer to the shore, they too could have been captured. Once they were
in the hunting area of the people, they were at their mercy. In the water is
where the whales are strongest. Mom, Dad and the sisters were devastated. A peaceful
night, turned tragic in an instant.
A few moments had passed and the family saw something
strange waving around in the water close to the shore. Dad quickly realized it
was hands of a human and rushed to the shore to snatch them. Just as quickly as Brother
had disappeared from the water, a woman disappeared from the shore. Dad angrily
dragged the woman back to their home. He wanted her to pay for what she had done
to his son and the impact it would have on his family.
Mom and the sisters swam behind Dad all the way home. They
were unsure what his plans were, but they didn’t question his intentions
either. As the three arrived home, they couldn’t find Dad or the woman
anywhere. They looked all around and there was no sign of them. After a few
moments passed, Dad came to them without the woman. He explained that
she was now their slave. She would be doing anything they ask without
hesitation. Dad said that the woman realized what she had done and was willing
to make it up to them by doing so. She felt terribly guilty for what she and
her husband had done to Brother.
A few days had passed since the people took brother. The
woman was living up to her word. She took care of the chores around the house,
hunted dinner for the family and helped the sisters with their school work. Even though it was under tragic circumstances, the family came to enjoy having the woman around. Shortly after she finished preparing
dinner, her husband and a shark barged into the whales’ home. They demanded
that the family release his wife. Her husband was shocked when she was
the one that denied their request. He thought that she would be thrilled to be
rescued.
She explained her reasoning for refusing to go home with
them. She wanted to make things right with the family.
"We once had a son," she began to explain. "One night we were outside enjoying the clear skies and calm breeze when a group from a neighboring tribe ambushed my son, husband and me."
"They kidnapped my son and we lost hope of ever seeing him again. I couldn't eat or sleep for months afterwards. When I closed my eyes, I could hear my son's screams as they ripped him out of my arms. If I could take back what we did to your son, I would. Since I cannot, I want to stay with your family," she said as she made eye contact with Dad.
She turned to her husband and said, "I want to make things right with them. I will be staying in the water. I know you don't understand, but this is what I have to do."
"We once had a son," she began to explain. "One night we were outside enjoying the clear skies and calm breeze when a group from a neighboring tribe ambushed my son, husband and me."
"They kidnapped my son and we lost hope of ever seeing him again. I couldn't eat or sleep for months afterwards. When I closed my eyes, I could hear my son's screams as they ripped him out of my arms. If I could take back what we did to your son, I would. Since I cannot, I want to stay with your family," she said as she made eye contact with Dad.
She turned to her husband and said, "I want to make things right with them. I will be staying in the water. I know you don't understand, but this is what I have to do."
Her husband remembered the heartache she went through during
that time and agreed to let her stay. Though he was heartbroken, he and Shark
turned and left the whales’ residence. Little did he know that he would also
never see his wife again.
After hearing what the man and woman had gone through with their own son, the whales felt they had a better connection with her. The relationship between them grew to something more than master and captive. Soon, she became one of the family.
Author’s Note: The original story is about a man and woman
that capture a friend of the whales and kill it for food. When the woman goes back to the
water to clean her hands, she is then taken by the whale’s friends. They took
her back to their home and made her their slave as revenge for the killing of
their friend. The woman’s husband then goes into the water in search for his
wife. He came to the house of the fish-chief and asked for help in searching
for his wife. Shark was the one chosen to help the man in his quest. The two
came across the killer whales and the wife. Shark pushed the wife towards the
husband and told them to run and he would stay back and fight the whales.
I chose to change the story to the perspective of the
whales, to give the reader the other side of the story. I also changed it from
being friends to being family as I thought this would give a more solid reason
for the whales to take revenge in the way that they did. In the end, I decided
to make the woman want to stay with the whales to make up for the events her
and her husband played a part. Since the two had gone through the same sort of
tragedy, I thought it would be good that she could relate to the whales and
want to make it up to them.
Tales of the North American Indians by Stith Thompson; The Woman Stolen By Killer Whales
I think the point of view switch is interesting and the way you characterized the whales was nice and effective. The scene with the brother whale looking up at the stars was a great way to make him sympathetic and make the audience feel bad for his family when he was taken. Naming the constellations was a nice touch, too.
ReplyDeleteIf you’re going to do edits, I would suggest doing more work on the ending. It took me a couple readings to “get” the ending, and I’m not one hundred percent sure what you’re getting at yet. The woman chose to stay with the whales because she enjoyed working for them—more than being with her husband? It would be nice to hear her thoughts about why that’s the case. Is it about punishing the husband, or is his end supposed to be tragic and undeserved because he didn’t know what he was doing? To be fair, I haven’t read the original, so it might be more about coming up with an explanation the story lacked.
I liked your take on this story. Keep going!
I really enjoyed how you retold the story. I found the relation between the whales and the woman to be interesting. You did well introducing the Brother and his family in the beginning; this created a sense of loss because the reader was able to understand his character and passions before he was killed. You never gave the characters names which is fine since a lot of Native American tales do not give characters names, but you referred to the whales as brother, sisters and dad. If that is the case, then you should capitalize them because they are titles/names of the whales.
ReplyDeleteI also really liked the last line of the story when it referred back to never seeing his son or his wife again. However, I would have thought the Husband would have tried to talk the wife out of staying and coming back with him and Shark, though this ending keeps the theme of loss going throughout the story.
Great job!
Your title for your story definitely intrigued me. I think it was a very cool detail about the twinkles being a kind of communication. I like how the whale family did things like humans do like school and housework. Your story was very sad, but I did like how the woman did what was right, even though it was hard for her. I think all the changes you made to the story were great!
ReplyDeleteI thought your story was from a super unique perspective! I liked that the woman wanted to atone for her sins, but I found the ending unnecessarily ominous for what I viewed to be a relatively happy end. However, I did find it confusing whenever the whale characters were referred to without being capitalized. I liked the Brother/Mother/Sisters thing so when they were lowercase I got confused. But overall it was a really entertaining read!
ReplyDeleteOh, I read this story too!! I really like your reinterpretation. It always seemed very unfair to me that the people had no sympathy for the killer whales. Even Shark was on their side! I liked how the woman decided to sacrifice herself to repay the whales even though she didn't have to and could have gone home with her husband. I did feel bad for him though as he just wanted his wife back and didn't realize how much he was hurting the killer whales. I liked the beginning too when you were describing the brother's wonder at the world. It makes it so much worse when they kill him! As one of the commenters mentioned above, the capitalization when it comes to Brother and Sisters is a bit of an issue. I think as long as you stay consistent and always capitalize brother when referring to the killer whale it won't be an issue! Great story though!
ReplyDeleteI liked your story a lot, Melanie. I liked your interpretation of the original story and how you made your story so unique while also keeping the heart of it. I also like the writing style that you use in your stories. It makes the story enjoyable to read and helps it flow well from one paragraph to another. I wasn't expecting the woman and the killer whales to end up enjoying each other's company though. Great job!
ReplyDelete